When to buy stocks? Why there is no perfect time
Nobody can reliably predict a perfect time to buy stocks. Prices react to news that nobody knows in advance, and the lowest price is only recognized afterwards. Instead of waiting for the right moment, you can set a fixed process: review date, selection criteria and exit rule. That doesn't prevent losses either.
In short
- This page doesn't answer whether now is a good time. Nobody can say that reliably.
- Time of day is mainly about costs: early in the morning and late in the evening, the spread between bid and ask can be wider.
- Patterns by weekday and month have been studied. Some later became weaker or disappeared.
- Fixed rules replace guessing with a process. They don't prevent losses.
- German consumer advice centers advise not to invest money in equity ETFs that you urgently need in the next few years. Prices can fall, with individual stocks down to a total loss.
As of 11/16/2026
No answer to "now or later?", but a daily sorting by relative strength.
Go to the scannerWhy timing is so hard
Prices move when new information emerges. Nobody knows it in advance, not even professionals. If you wait for the lowest price, you only see it when prices have already risen again. The ETF portal justETF writes that even financial market professionals find it hard to find the right entry point.
Strong and weak days are often close together. According to an analysis by Hartford Funds (data from Ned Davis Research, as of April 2025), in the US S&P 500 index, measured as a price index in US dollars without dividends, about 42 percent of the strongest days from 2003 to 03/2025 fell in a bear market, and another 36 percent in the first two months of a bull market, before it was recognizable as such. This shows how hard it is to tell good and bad phases apart in the moment. It is not a statement about future days.
Then there are feelings: after a rise, buying feels easy; after a decline, hard. How investors deal with falling and rising prices is described on the page Buy stocks when they fall or when they rise?; what makes a bear market has its own page.
Time of day, weekday, month: what's behind it
Time of day. Every trading venue has its own trading hours. What matters most is the bid-ask spread, that is the difference between the price at which you buy and the price at which you could sell. According to the German consumer advice centers, those who trade early in the morning or late in the evening pay worse prices on average. For ETFs with US stocks traded in Europe, they name the period when New York is also trading (usually from 3:30 p.m. German time, 9:30 a.m. New York time). This concerns costs, not the direction of the price.
Weekday. Older studies, for example by Kenneth French (1980), described weaker returns over the weekend in the US market; Robins and Smith (2016) no longer found the effect after 1975.
Month. "Sell in May and go away" is a well-known stock market saying. Bouman and Jacobsen studied it in 2002 under the title "The Halloween Indicator" and themselves called it a puzzle. No study can promise whether such a pattern will appear in the future.
Calendar patterns are therefore no substitute for a rule. If you trade, pay attention mainly to costs when it comes to time of day.
A rule instead of a moment
Instead of guessing a moment, you can set in advance how you proceed. Three building blocks:
- Prerequisites. Germany's financial regulator BaFin names an emergency reserve in a savings or overnight money account and considers stocks unsuitable for it. The Association of German Banks names an investment period of at least ten years. Losses are possible even over long periods.
- A fixed date. A savings plan invests a fixed amount at a fixed rhythm, regardless of the price. A savings plan also fluctuates with the market and can be in the red. What matters with small amounts is covered under stocks with little money. If you watch individual securities, you can choose a fixed review date; more on this under How often should you check your portfolio?
- Criteria. You set in advance by which characteristic you select securities and why. Ways to do this are described on the page How do I find good stocks?
Such a process doesn't answer the question "now or later?"; it replaces it with fixed dates. But it can also mean that you buy at a time after which prices fall at first.
How a method sets entry and exit
The method by Levy is an example of a fixed process. It uses relative strength (RSL), that is the price divided by its own average price, and compares all securities of an index with it. The method's entry rules are on the strategy page. A security is held as long as it is in the top 25 percent of the index and its RSL stays above 1. On the 26-week basis, the method provides for a check once a week.
Here the timing doesn't come from a feeling but from the review date and the conditions. That makes decisions traceable. But the rules can also lead to purchases shortly before a decline or to sales shortly before a recovery, and the strategy page points out that the method can perform worse in bear markets or sideways phases. This description is not a call to act according to the method.
RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength within one market; the ranking is re-sorted once a day. RSL-scan is a paid tool with the Light and Premium subscriptions; details under pricing.
This is what a ranking by relative strength looks like, re-sorted once a day.
View the rankingLimits
- No forecast. Neither a calendar pattern nor a rule says how a price will develop.
- Costs. Every purchase and sale costs fees and spread. Frequent reallocating increases costs.
- Discipline. A rule makes decisions traceable, but only works if you stick to it even in turbulent phases. Typical pitfalls are described on the page about beginner mistakes.
- Exit. If you set rules for the entry, you also need a rule for the exit. Examples are under When to sell stocks?
Method and author
RSL-scan editorial team. This page explains basics and does not replace investment advice. It doesn't answer whether now is a good time. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. RSL-scan is a paid tool with the Light and Premium subscriptions (see pricing). The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. Consumer information according to BaFin, the Association of German Banks and the German consumer advice centers, US market figures according to Hartford Funds (data: Ned Davis Research, as of 04/2025), research according to French (1980), Robins and Smith (2016) and Bouman and Jacobsen (2002), links below. As of 11/16/2026.
Frequently asked questions
When to buy and sell stocks?
There is no generally right time, because nobody knows future prices. An alternative is a fixed process: a review date, clear criteria for selection and a rule for selling that you set in advance. Losses are possible even then.
When should you start buying stocks?
BaFin names an emergency reserve and a look at existing loans; the Association of German Banks names a long investment period. Stock prices fluctuate; with individual stocks, a total loss is possible.
Does it make sense to buy stocks now?
This page can't answer that, and nobody can give a reliable answer, because future prices are unknown. Whether investing in stocks suits you depends on your time horizon, reserve, costs and your willingness to endure losses.
What time of day should you buy stocks?
There is no reliably better time of day for the direction of the price. According to the German consumer advice centers, those who trade early in the morning or late in the evening pay worse prices on average, because the spread between bid and ask can then be wider.
On which weekday should you buy stocks?
A previously described Monday effect with weaker returns at the start of the week was no longer found in a study by Robins and Smith for the period after 1975. A weekday with reliably better prices is not proven.
Should you buy stocks or not?
That depends on your situation, not on the calendar. Stocks can fluctuate for a long time and bring losses. BaFin points out that the higher the promised return, the higher the risk of capital loss. There is no general answer or promise.
Sources
- RSL-scan, home page and FAQ: RSL-scan. Ranking by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market, re-sorting once a day, no forecast, Light and Premium subscriptions.
- RSL-scan, strategy page: RSL-scan: Strategy. RSL = price ÷ average price, entry rules of the method, holding in the top 25 percent with RSL above 1, weekly check on the 26-week basis, note on bear markets and sideways phases.
- RSL-scan, pricing: RSL-scan: Plans and pricing. Light and Premium subscriptions.
- justETF: Markt-Timing: Wann ist der richtige Einstiegszeitpunkt an der Börse? (02/23/2024, in German). Right entry point hard to find, even for financial market professionals.
- Hartford Funds: 10 Things You Should Know About Bear Markets (PDF). Data from Ned Davis Research (as of 04/2025), S&P 500 as a price index in US dollars: about 42 percent of the strongest days from 2003 to 03/2025 in a bear market, another 36 percent in the first two months of a bull market.
- Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center): Neobroker: Kosten und Risiken des schnellen Wertpapier-Handels per App (in German). Bid-ask spread, worse prices early in the morning and late in the evening, ETFs with US stocks from 3:30 p.m. German time.
- French, Kenneth R. (1980): "Stock Returns and the Weekend Effect". Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 55-69. RePEc: Stock returns and the weekend effect.
- Robins, Russell P.; Smith, Geoffrey Peter (2016): "No More Weekend Effect". Critical Finance Review, vol. 5, pp. 417-424. Article (PDF).
- Bouman, Sven; Jacobsen, Ben (2002): "The Halloween Indicator, 'Sell in May and Go Away': Another Puzzle". American Economic Review, vol. 92, no. 5, pp. 1618-1635. RePEc: The Halloween Indicator.
- BaFin: Das kleine Einmaleins der Geldanlage (in German). Emergency reserve, stocks unsuitable as an emergency reserve, debts, the higher the promised return, the greater the risk of capital loss.
- Bankenverband (Association of German Banks): Fünf Tipps, wenn Sie in Aktien und Fonds investieren wollen (in German). Investment period of at least ten years, costs of reallocating.
- Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center): ETF für Anfänger: Die häufigsten Fragen einfach erklärt (in German). Don't invest money in equity ETFs that you urgently need in the next few years.
- Levy, Robert A. (1967): "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection". The Journal of Finance, vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 595-610. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1967.tb00295.x.
No forecast, no buy or sell signals. Just a sorted overview.
Go to the scannerNot a buy recommendation. Not investment advice. Investments carry risks of loss up to and including total loss. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.