Abstract line crossing a horizontal threshold on a dark background, symbolizing an exit rule

When to sell stocks? Exit rules instead of gut feeling

There is no generally right time to sell. What helps is an exit rule that you set before buying, for example a stop-loss or a criterion such as a security's rank compared with others. That way, selling does not depend on your mood on any given day.

In short

  • Many people find selling harder than buying, because losses feel stronger than gains of the same size.
  • Your own purchase price means nothing to the market, but it often influences the decision.
  • An exit rule sets in advance the condition under which a position is closed.
  • Levy's RSL method ties the exit to the rank of relative strength, not to a percentage of the purchase price.
  • No rule prevents losses. It only makes decisions more traceable.

As of 11/16/2026

Check the rank of your securities using a fixed rule instead of gut feeling.

Go to the scanner

Why selling is harder than buying

Buying is exciting. You have an idea, you act. Selling, on the other hand, almost always comes with an unpleasant feeling. Either you admit that it didn't work out. Or you are afraid the price will keep rising after you sell.

Behavioral economics has a name for this. In 1979, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky described that people weight losses more heavily than gains of the same size. Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman later showed that investors tend to sell winners too early and hold losers too long. They called this the disposition effect.

In short: when it comes to selling, your gut is not a neutral adviser.

Typical thinking errors

Fear of losses

A security is in the red. As long as you don't sell, the loss doesn't feel quite real. So you wait. That is human, but the loss is already in your portfolio whether you sell or not.

The purchase price as an anchor

Many people wait for the price to get "at least back to where I bought". An example (sample figures): you bought at $50, now the price is $40. The question "sell or hold?" actually has nothing to do with the $50. The market doesn't know your purchase price. All that matters is how you assess the security today.

Taking profits too early

The flip side: a security rises 10% and you sell quickly to lock in the gain. That feels good. But it can lead to you keeping the weak securities and giving up the strong ones. That is exactly what the disposition effect describes.

Example of a rule: rank and RSL

An exit rule takes the decision off your hands in the moment. You set in advance what has to happen. Then you only check whether the condition has occurred.

Robert Levy's method is one example. It doesn't look at your purchase price, but at relative strength by Levy and a security's rank within its market. The method holds a position as long as the security is in the top 25% of its index and its RSL is above 1. If it drops out of the top 25% or its RSL falls below 1, the strategy calls for selling. You will find the exact rules of the RSL strategy on a separate page.

An example (sample values): a security in an index of 40 is at rank 6. A few weeks later it has slipped to rank 14. That puts it outside the top 25%, which end at rank 10. Under the rule, now would be the time to review the position, regardless of whether it is showing a gain or a loss.

Sample chart: ranking in which a placeholder security slips down over time and falls below a threshold line, no recommendation

RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. In the scanner, securities outside the top 25% are marked in red. So you can see at a glance which securities no longer meet the rank criterion. If you want to keep an eye on selected securities, put them on a watchlist.

Recreated sample view of RSL-scan. Values for illustration only, not a recommendation.

Securities outside the top 25% are marked in red in the scanner.

View the ranking

Rule-based exit and stop-loss compared

The best-known exit rule is the stop-loss. You set a price, for example 10% below the purchase price (sample figure), and sell automatically when it is reached.

Both approaches share one strength: the decision is made in advance. But they differ in their reference point. The stop-loss is tied to the purchase price or a fixed price level. A rank-based exit is tied to the comparison with other securities. So a security can be showing a gain and still drop out of the top quarter. Conversely, a stop-loss can be triggered by a short pullback even though the security remains strong by comparison.

Levy's pure RSL strategy, by the way, works without a stop-loss, because it relies on relative strength and not on absolute prices. Which reference point fits better depends on your method. What matters is that there is one at all.

No rule fits everyone

A rule is not a shield. It cannot prevent losses, and in hectic phases it sometimes gives signals that turn out to be unnecessary in hindsight. Then there are costs: every sale incurs fees and can have tax consequences.

How long you hold a stock therefore depends on more than one metric. Your time horizon, your goals and how much fluctuation you can stand all play a part. Above all, a rule makes your decisions traceable. And if the opposite question is on your mind, when to get in at all, read on at buy stocks when they fall or when they rise?

A rule makes decisions traceable. You see the rank in the scanner.

View the ranking

Method and author

RSL-scan editorial team. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. All calculations use sample figures. As of 11/16/2026.

Frequently asked questions

When should you sell stocks?

There is no fixed point in time that suits everyone. A rule you set before buying helps, such as a stop-loss or a criterion like the rank compared with other securities. That way you don't decide based on the mood of the day.

When to sell stocks at a loss?

Many people hold losers too long because they are waiting for the old purchase price. But the purchase price plays no role in what happens next. An exit rule sets in advance the condition under which a position is closed, regardless of whether it shows a gain or a loss.

Is there a fixed percentage at which to sell?

There is no generally right percentage. Some use a stop-loss at a fixed distance from the purchase price, for example 10%. Levy's RSL method instead uses the rank within a market and the RSL rather than a percentage.

How long should you hold stocks?

That depends on your method and your time horizon. If you follow rules, you hold a security as long as the rule is met and check this on a fixed schedule. There is no minimum holding period that always fits.

Is it worth selling securities for a $1 gain?

With very small gains, order fees can eat up all or part of the profit. Whether a sale is worthwhile also depends on your rule and on tax questions. Tax details are best clarified with a tax advisor.

When does Levy's RSL strategy call for selling?

The method holds a position as long as the security is in the top 25% of its market and its RSL is above 1. If it drops out of the top 25% or its RSL falls below 1, the strategy calls for selling. A stop-loss is not part of the pure strategy.

Sources

The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast.

Go to the scanner

Not a buy recommendation / not investment advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.