Buy stocks when they fall or when they rise?
Whether you should buy stocks when they fall or when they rise cannot be answered in general. There are two schools of thought: one buys after prices have fallen and hopes for a recovery. The other follows securities that have already done better than others (momentum). Both carry risks; neither offers a guarantee.
In short
- Buying more as prices fall lowers your average price, but at the same time increases your stake in a security that is currently weak.
- Momentum means watching securities that have done better than others over recent months.
- Studies have described a momentum effect in historical data, but also severe setbacks of such strategies.
- An all-time high on its own says neither that a price is too expensive nor that it will keep rising.
- Levy's method looks at the rank of relative strength, not at whether a price is high or low.
As of 11/16/2026
Rank instead of price level: see how the securities of a market are sorted.
Go to the scannerTwo schools of thought: buy the dip or follow strength
Almost everyone who starts out asks this question. One price has fallen, so it looks cheap. Another is at a record, so it looks expensive. Gut feeling has a clear opinion here. The numbers are less clear-cut.
The idea behind buying more
If you buy more, you are betting that a price will return to its earlier level. An example (sample figures): you bought 10 shares at $100. The price falls to $80 and you buy another 10. Your average price is now $90. If the price rises back to $90, you break even.
That sounds elegant. But there is a catch: you now have twice as much money in a security that is doing worse than before. Whether it recovers, nobody knows.
The idea behind momentum
The second school turns the logic around. It doesn't ask what looks cheap, but what is currently running strongly. Behind momentum stocks is the observation that strength can persist for a while. The focus here is not the low, but relative strength.
What research on momentum says, and what it doesn't
The best-known evidence comes from Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Sheridan Titman. In 1993 they studied US stocks and described that securities with strong performance in the preceding months, on average in historical data, continued to do better than weak ones for a while. Since then the effect has been studied in many markets.
Now comes the "but", and it is important. The effect is an average across many securities and long periods. It says nothing about a single stock. In addition, there were phases in which momentum strategies lost heavily, especially at sharp market turns. Kent Daniel and Tobias Moskowitz studied exactly these crashes.
So what research does not say: that what is rising will surely keep rising. It describes a past tendency, with risks.
The all-time high: a psychological hurdle
"Should I buy stocks at an all-time high?" That is the question here. It is understandable. A record price feels dangerous, as if you were standing at the edge of a cliff.
Purely mathematically, though, an all-time high is just a price that is higher than all previous ones. For a security that rises over years, this happens quite often. On its own, a high is neither a warning sign nor a starting signal. Thomas George and Chuan-Yang Hwang studied the 52-week high in 2004. Their interpretation: many investors use the high as an anchor and react too hesitantly to new information near it. In their historical data, securities close to their high did, on average, rather better than securities far below it. That too is an average, not a statement about a single stock.
A related question: "Should I invest less because the market is at an all-time high?" There is no blanket answer. It depends on your time horizon and your risk tolerance.
Close to the high or far below it: the ranking shows the comparison within the market.
View the rankingBuying more at a loss: the risks
Buying more can seem sensible if you hold a security for the long term and are convinced of it. But it has three typical risks.
First, concentration risk grows. Suddenly one security makes up a large part of your portfolio. Second, you anchor yourself to the old purchase price. The price back then is completely irrelevant to the market; it only matters in your head. Third, a price that has fallen can keep falling. A security that falls from 100 to 50 (sample figures) has lost 50%. To get back to 100, it needs a gain of 100%.
The question "does it make sense to buy more?" can therefore only be answered with "it depends". If you buy more, you should know why and decide in advance how far you will go.
How the RSL method deals with this: rank instead of price level
Robert Levy's method asks a different question. Not: is the price high or low? But: how strong is the security compared with the others in the same market?
To answer it, relative strength by Levy divides the current price by its average price over a fixed period. A security that has just fallen usually has a low RSL and slips down the ranking. A security close to its high is often further up. That is not a judgment; it is simply the calculation.
RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. So the method looks at strength rather than at fallen prices. Whether this approach suits you is your decision. You will find the exact rules of the RSL strategy on a separate page. The scanner shows what the daily ranking looks like.
And because buying is only half the decision: how to plan the exit with rules is covered on the page When to sell stocks?. If you want to learn to read a chart first, start with How do I spot a trend?
Whether the approach suits you is your decision. Take a look at the daily ranking.
View the rankingMethod and author
RSL-scan editorial team. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. Research on momentum is cited only qualitatively, without return figures. All calculations use sample figures. As of 11/16/2026.
Frequently asked questions
Should you buy stocks when they fall?
That cannot be answered in general. Falling prices look cheap but can keep falling, and a low price is no proof of a good security. That is why the momentum idea deliberately focuses on strength rather than on fallen prices.
Does it make sense to buy more of a stock?
Buying more lowers your average price but increases your stake in a security that is currently weak. Whether that suits you depends on your reason for holding it, your time horizon and how your portfolio is split. What matters is deciding in advance how far you will go.
Should you buy stocks at an all-time high?
An all-time high is just a price that is higher than all previous ones. On its own it says neither that the security is too expensive nor that it will keep rising. The decision should depend on a method, not on the size of a number.
Buying more at a loss: what is the risk?
The main risk is that the price keeps falling and your loss in a single security grows. Then there is the anchoring effect: you hold on to the old purchase price even though it plays no role in what happens next. A security that has lost 50% needs a 100% gain to get back to where it started (sample calculation).
Buying stocks when they rise: is it too late?
Not necessarily. Studies have described that, in historical data, strength could persist for a while on average, but they also show significant setbacks. There is no certainty about this for a single stock.
What does contrarian investing mean?
Contrarian means acting against the current direction: buying after prices have fallen and reducing after they have risen. Pro-cyclical is the opposite. Momentum is a pro-cyclical idea because it looks at securities that have already run strongly.
Sources
- RSL-scan, home page and FAQ: RSL-scan. Ranking by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market, re-sorting once a day, no forecast.
- Jegadeesh, Narasimhan; Titman, Sheridan (1993): "Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers: Implications for Stock Market Efficiency". The Journal of Finance, vol. 48, no. 1, pp. 65-91. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1993.tb04702.x.
- Daniel, Kent; Moskowitz, Tobias J. (2016): "Momentum crashes". Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 122, no. 2, pp. 221-247. DOI 10.1016/j.jfineco.2015.12.002.
- George, Thomas J.; Hwang, Chuan-Yang (2004): "The 52-Week High and Momentum Investing". The Journal of Finance, vol. 59, no. 5, pp. 2145-2176. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.2004.00695.x.
- Levy, Robert A. (1967): "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection". The Journal of Finance, vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 595-610. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1967.tb00295.x.
- fondsfueralle.de, financial glossary: Antizyklisches Anlageverhalten (in German). Contrarian and pro-cyclical.
- The calculations are sample figures.
The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast.
Go to the scannerNot a buy recommendation / not investment advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.