ETF or individual stocks? An honest comparison for beginners
Whether an ETF or individual stocks suit you better depends on your goal, your time and your risk tolerance. A broad equity ETF spreads across many hundreds of companies and takes little work. Individual stocks allow a targeted selection but mean more effort and a higher single-stock risk. The two can also be combined, for example as core and addition.
In short
- A stock is a share in a company. A passive ETF is an exchange-traded fund that tracks an index.
- An ETF on the MSCI World covers more than a thousand companies. For diversification with individual stocks, you need many securities yourself.
- ETFs have ongoing costs; individual stocks don't. Order fees apply to both.
- Consumer organizations such as Germany's Stiftung Warentest name broadly diversified equity ETFs as the basis.
- If you also watch individual stocks, you'll be more traceable with fixed rules than with tips.
As of 11/16/2026
For the part where you watch individual stocks: a ranking by relative strength.
Go to the scannerWhat an ETF is and what an individual stock is
Individual stock. With a stock you own a small part of a company. If things go well, the price can rise and there may be a dividend. If things go badly, the price can fall, in the worst case to zero. As a shareholder you have a vote at the annual general meeting.
ETF. ETF stands for exchange-traded fund, that is a fund that is traded on the stock exchange. A passive equity ETF tracks an index, for example the S&P 500 with around 500 large US companies or the MSCI World with 1,248 companies from developed countries (as of 10/30/2026). With one unit you buy the whole basket at once. How such a basket is put together is explained on the page What is a stock index?
The difference in one sentence: with a stock you bet on one company, with a broad ETF on an entire market.
Diversification, costs, effort compared
| Feature | Individual stock | Broad equity ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Diversification | One company; you have to build diversification yourself | Many companies in one unit |
| Single-stock risk | Total loss of one security possible | Failure of one company carries little weight |
| Market risk | Yes | Yes, the ETF falls with its market |
| Ongoing costs | No ongoing fund costs | Ongoing costs (expense ratio) |
| Order fees | Depending on provider | Depending on provider |
| Effort | High: select, watch, decide | Low: the index decides the composition |
| Voting rights | You exercise them yourself | Held by the fund |
On diversification: how many individual stocks are needed before further securities hardly reduce risk any more is disputed. Depending on the assumptions, studies name very different numbers; more on this under How many stocks belong in a portfolio?
On risk: even a broad ETF fluctuates. Germany's financial regulator BaFin points out that diversification only protects as long as the entire asset class doesn't fall. How fluctuations are measured is explained on the page about volatility.
Why ETFs are named as the basis
Consumer advocates are fairly clear here. Stiftung Warentest recommends globally diversified ETFs for investing in stocks and individual stocks only as an addition. The German consumer advice centers advise broad diversification through equity ETFs instead of a few individual stocks. BaFin describes passive ETFs as a way to invest relatively conveniently, cheaply and with broad diversification.
The reasons are in the table: an ETF takes selection and diversification off your hands. You don't have to read annual reports or find a timing for each individual security. For getting started, that's a strong argument, especially if you have little time or are still learning. More basics for the start are on the page Stocks for beginners.
To be honest: if you are only looking for a simple, broad solution, you don't need a stock scanner.
If you still look at individual stocks: with rules
There are reasons to look at individual stocks. According to justETF, only this way can you deliberately exclude individual companies or weight them more heavily, and following a company's development is less abstract than with a fund. The same source also names the downside: more effort, less diversification and a greater tendency to make gut decisions.
That's exactly where fixed rules help. Instead of tips from forums or headlines, you set in advance by which criterion you compare securities and how often you look.
One example of such a criterion is relative strength by Levy: the current price divided by its average. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The ranking is re-sorted once a day. According to the strategy page, the method by Levy works with about five equally sized positions. The strategy page explicitly names higher volatility from concentrating on top performers as a risk.
A rule makes your selection traceable. It says nothing about how a price will develop in the future and doesn't protect against losses.
One criterion instead of tips: see how a market is sorted by relative strength.
View the rankingCombining a core and watching
ETF or individual stocks doesn't have to be either-or. Vanguard and Commerzbank describe the core-satellite strategy for this: a broadly diversified ETF forms the core, smaller individual investments complement it as satellites. Commerzbank gives a split of 80% core to 20% satellites as an example.
The addition doesn't have to be bought right away. You can also just watch at first: choose a market, read the ranking and put a few securities on a watchlist. That way you learn how individual securities behave without the core of your portfolio depending on it.
If you want to know whether there is a middle way via funds that themselves select by strength, you'll find the classification under Momentum ETF or your own rules?
Method and author
RSL-scan editorial team. This page compares ETFs and individual stocks and does not replace investment advice. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. Consumer information according to BaFin, the German consumer advice centers and Stiftung Warentest, comparison details according to justETF, Vanguard and Commerzbank (links below). As of 11/16/2026.
Frequently asked questions
What are ETFs?
ETFs are funds that are traded on the stock exchange. Passive ETFs track an index, for example the S&P 500 or the MSCI World. With one unit you hold a stake in all companies in the index, according to their weighting.
Which is better, ETF or stocks?
That depends on your goal, time and risk tolerance. A broad ETF diversifies widely and takes little work. Individual stocks allow a targeted selection but take more time and carry a higher single-stock risk. Stiftung Warentest names broadly diversified ETFs as the basis and individual stocks as an addition.
Which is safer, ETF or stocks?
A broadly diversified ETF doesn't depend on a single company, so the single-stock risk is much smaller. It isn't safe in the sense of loss-free: if the whole market falls, the ETF falls too. With an individual stock, a total loss is also possible.
Which pays off more, ETF or stocks?
Nobody knows in advance. An ETF develops like its index. With individual stocks, you can do better or worse than the market. Past performance is not a reliable indication of future results.
Which is better: ETF, mutual fund or stocks?
An active fund is run by a management team that selects securities. A passive ETF only tracks an index; BaFin calls passive ETFs inexpensive. With stocks, you choose yourself. Which form suits you depends on how much of the selection you want to make yourself.
Does it make sense to invest in ETFs?
That depends on your situation. BaFin describes passive ETFs as a convenient, inexpensive and broadly diversified investment, but points out the market risk. Before that, an emergency reserve and a long time horizon should be clarified. This page does not replace a personal recommendation.
Sources
- RSL-scan, home page and FAQ: RSL-scan. Ranking by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market, re-sorting once a day, no forecast, watchlist.
- RSL-scan, strategy page: RSL-scan: Strategy. About five equally sized positions, risk of higher volatility from concentrating on top performers.
- BaFin: Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) im Überblick (in German). Passive ETFs track indices, relatively convenient, inexpensive and broadly diversified; diversification doesn't protect when the entire asset class falls.
- BaFin: Das kleine Einmaleins der Geldanlage (in German). Emergency reserve, investment horizon.
- Verbraucherzentrale (German consumer advice center): Investieren in Aktien-ETFs: So streuen Sie das Risiko richtig (in German). Broad diversification through equity ETFs instead of a few individual stocks.
- Stiftung Warentest: Streuung bei der Geldanlage: Sind Einzelaktien besser als ETF? (in German). World equity ETF as the basis, individual stocks as an addition.
- justETF: Aktien oder ETFs? (in German). Comparison of effort, diversification, ongoing costs, voting rights, out- and underperformance possible, reasons for individual stocks.
- justETF: MSCI World-ETFs im Vergleich (in German). MSCI World with 1,248 companies (as of 10/30/2026).
- Vanguard: ETFs oder Aktien: Was eignet sich besser zum Investieren? (in German). No ongoing fund costs for individual stocks, voting rights, market risk of ETFs, core-satellite.
- Commerzbank: Core Satellite Strategie (in German). Core and satellites, example 80% to 20%.
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: S&P 500. Around 500 large US companies.
No forecast, no buy or sell signals. Just a sorted overview, updated once a day.
Go to the scannerNot a buy recommendation / not investment advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.