Momentum ETF or your own rules? What's behind the factor
A momentum ETF tracks an index that selects the stocks with the strongest price performance of the past months from a broad market. The index provider sets the rules. With your own ranking by relative strength, you set the rules yourself and bear the effort and costs yourself. Both can fluctuate more than the broad market.
In short
- A factor ETF tracks an index that selects and weights stocks by a characteristic such as momentum.
- Common momentum indices measure price performance over 6 and 12 months and leave out the most recent month.
- Levy's RSL, on the other hand, measures the distance of the price from its own average.
- With the ETF, the index provider decides; with your own ranking, you decide.
- Momentum can fall particularly sharply during sudden trend reversals.
As of 11/16/2026
See momentum for yourself: all securities of an index by relative strength.
Go to the scannerWhat a factor ETF is
A classic ETF tracks an index, such as a broad world index in which large companies are weighted by their market value. A factor ETF also tracks an index. But its rules select and weight the stocks by a specific characteristic, the factor. Momentum is one of them; others are, for example, value or low volatility.
Germany's financial regulator BaFin describes the core like this: with a passive ETF, the manager has no leeway in either selection or weighting. With ETFs on a special index, you have to trust the selection by the index provider. That is convenient because the work is done for you, and at the same time a dependency: you adopt rules you cannot influence.
How momentum indices select stocks
The idea behind momentum is well described in research. In 1993, Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Sheridan Titman showed for the US stock market that stocks that were strong in the past months continued to do better on average in the following months than weak ones. They gave back part of this in the years that followed. A finding about the past, not a promise for the future.
How a momentum index implements this is shown in MSCI's public methodology document for its momentum indices (as of July 2025). Simplified:
- The starting point is a parent index, for example a world index.
- For each stock, the price performance over 6 and over 12 months is calculated, each without the most recent month and minus a short-term interest rate.
- Both values are divided by the stock's volatility. Calm securities with the same rise thus score better than erratic ones.
- A fixed number of stocks with the highest momentum score is included in the index.
- Weighting is by market value times momentum score, with a cap per company.
- The index is reviewed quarterly, and additionally outside the schedule after strong market moves.
Other index providers calculate differently. Which rules apply to a particular product is stated in its documents.
Differences from the RSL method
Relative strength by Levy, described by Robert Levy in 1967, measures something different: it divides the current price by its own average, at RSL-scan over 26 weeks or 26 days. The RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it works with a ranking within an index, about five equally sized positions from the top ranks and fixed exit rules.
| Momentum index (example: MSCI methodology) | RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it | |
|---|---|---|
| Metric | Price performance over 6 and 12 months, without the latest month, divided by volatility | Price ÷ own average over 26 weeks or 26 days |
| Selection | Fixed number of stocks from the parent index | About 5 securities from the top ranks of an index, RSL above 1 |
| Weighting | Market value times momentum score | Equally sized positions |
| Review | Quarterly, plus as needed | Weekly on the 26-week basis |
| Who decides | Index provider | You |
A momentum index often contains far more stocks than five, around 500 in MSCI's global momentum index according to the methodology document, and is therefore more broadly diversified. In return, it lags behind when strength in the market shifts. The RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it checks more often, weekly instead of quarterly on the 26-week basis. That also means more reallocations and costs, and the money is in few securities. According to the strategy page, this concentration brings higher fluctuations.
Price divided by its own average, for every security in the index. Re-sorted once a day.
View the rankingCosts, reallocation, transparency
An ETF has ongoing costs. BaFin refers to the key information document for this, which must state risks, costs and fees among other things. The fund takes care of the reallocations in the index; you only see them in the result.
With your own ranking you pay no fund costs, but order fees for every purchase and sale. The strategy page explicitly names transaction costs when switching positions as a risk. On top of that comes time for the weekly check, and you need the discipline to apply the rules even when it's uncomfortable. RSL-scan is a paid tool for this, with the Light and Premium subscriptions. The top places of the ranking are visible without a subscription.
On transparency: the rules of large momentum indices are public, but long and technical. The rules of the RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it fit on one page. Simpler doesn't mean better, though. Both paths rest on the same effect and have the same weakness.
No product recommendation
This weakness is called a momentum crash. During sudden trend reversals, the previous winners often fall the most. A momentum ETF can then lag behind the market until it is reallocated at the next date. With the RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it, the exit rules apply, but only on the next review date and at the prices then valid. Price gaps between two dates are not caught. According to the strategy page, a momentum strategy works best in rising markets and can be weaker in sideways and falling phases.
We don't name or rate any individual ETF here. Whether a factor ETF, a broad ETF or your own rules suit you depends on your goal, time and risk tolerance. A comparison of the basic question is on the page ETF or individual stocks?, more on the effect itself under momentum stocks and on fluctuations under volatility. The ranking shows how the securities of an index relate to each other by relative strength.
Method and author
RSL-scan editorial team. RSL-scan is a paid analysis tool (Light and Premium subscriptions); the top places of the ranking are visible without a subscription. RSL-scan ranks securities by relative strength (Levy RSL) within one market. The rankings are re-sorted once a day. No forecast. The basis is the ratio from R. A. Levy, "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection", Journal of Finance, 1967. RSL-scan calculates with 26 weeks or 26 days. All figures on this page are sample values or placeholders. As of 11/16/2026.
Frequently asked questions
What is a momentum ETF?
A momentum ETF is an exchange-traded index fund that tracks a momentum index. This index selects the stocks with the strongest price performance of the past months from a broad market. It can fluctuate more than a broad market ETF.
How does a momentum ETF work?
The index provider regularly calculates a momentum score for each stock in a parent index, for example from the price performance over 6 and 12 months. The stocks with the highest scores are included in the index. The ETF tracks it and reallocates on fixed dates.
Does a momentum ETF make sense?
That depends on your goal, time horizon and risk tolerance; we don't give a recommendation. A momentum ETF takes the selection off your hands and diversifies across many securities. At the same time, it has ongoing costs and can fall more sharply than the broad market during sudden trend reversals.
What is the difference between a momentum ETF and the MSCI World?
An ETF on the MSCI World tracks a broad equity index in which the companies are weighted by market value. A momentum index only takes part of these stocks, namely those with the highest momentum score, and additionally weights them by it. It is therefore less broad, and its composition can change more at the reviews. MSCI and the MSCI index names are trademarks of MSCI Inc. RSL-scan is not affiliated with MSCI. MSCI has neither reviewed nor endorsed this page.
What should I look for when comparing momentum ETFs?
The index rules (period, number of stocks, weighting, reallocation rhythm), the ongoing costs and the risks. Costs and risks are stated in the key information document or prospectus of the respective fund.
How does a momentum ETF differ from the RSL method?
The momentum index measures price performance over 6 and 12 months and weights by market value. Levy's RSL measures the distance of the price from its own average. The RSL strategy as RSL-scan describes it works with a few equally sized positions. With the ETF, the index provider decides; with the RSL strategy, you do.
Sources
- BaFin: Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) im Überblick (in German). Passive ETFs without leeway for the manager, trust in the index provider's selection for special indices, key information document with risks, costs and fees, market price risk.
- MSCI: MSCI Momentum Indexes Methodology (July 2025). Parent index, 6- and 12-month price performance without the latest month minus interest rate, risk adjustment, fixed number of stocks, weighting market value times momentum score, cap per issuer, quarterly review and additional review on triggers.
- MSCI and the MSCI index names are trademarks of MSCI Inc. RSL-scan is not affiliated with MSCI. MSCI has neither reviewed nor endorsed this page.
- Levy, Robert A. (1967): "Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection". The Journal of Finance, vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 595-610. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1967.tb00295.x. Summary: RePEc: Relative Strength as a Criterion for Investment Selection. Origin of the relative strength ratio (RSL), not of RSL-scan's rules.
- Jegadeesh, Narasimhan; Titman, Sheridan (1993): "Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers: Implications for Stock Market Efficiency". The Journal of Finance, vol. 48, no. 1, pp. 65-91. DOI 10.1111/j.1540-6261.1993.tb04702.x. Summary: RePEc: Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers.
- justETF: Momentum-ETFs (in German). Momentum over 6 or 12 months, higher volatility than broad market ETFs, momentum crashes during sudden corrections, lag until the next rebalancing.
- RSL-scan, strategy page: RSL-scan: Strategy. RSL = price ÷ average price, time frames 26 weeks and 26 days, about five equally sized positions, entry and exit rules, weekly check, higher volatility from concentration, transaction costs, weaker phases in bear markets and sideways phases.
- RSL-scan, home page and FAQ: RSL-scan. Ranking by relative strength within one market, Light and Premium subscriptions, re-sorting once a day.
No product recommendation, no forecast.
Go to the scannerNot a buy recommendation. Not investment advice. Investments carry risks of loss up to and including total loss. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results.